Global criticism of the treatment of hundreds of thousands of workers from international locations resembling Nepal, India and Bangladesh who’ve been constructing Qatar’s World Cup dream led to the Gulf state introducing a spread of labour coverage modifications that it says have improved the lives of the migrant workforce. Have these modifications labored and the way seemingly are they to be sustained after the match? A panel of consultants give their view.
Geoffrey: ‘Is it truthful play when there’s nothing for the employees?’
The World Cup is sort of a slap within the face of staff.
I’ve spoken to hundreds of them. They don’t know their rights; their contracts are violated; there’s discriminatory pay, after which there’s the climate. Persons are working in extreme temperatures. They get dehydrated. Staff have been dying of their sleep. These deaths could also be brought on by the work, and their households needs to be compensated.
Not less than there’s a minimal wage now. Earlier than, there was no approach you can complain about your wage, however now you understand you need to get a minimum of 1,000 rials a month (£245). The issue is that it’s too low. Approach too low. What number of billions of {dollars} has Qatar spent on preparations for the World Cup? The minimal wage is a drop within the ocean.
Kafala [a systemunder which workers cannot freely change jobs] was abolished for 2 or three months solely. After that, these highly effective Qataris who personal massive corporations complained and the modifications have been watered down. Now there’s a requirement to get your organization to approve your resignation. That is like bringing the kafala system once more by the again door.
The primary time I used to be detained in Qatar was for attempting to vary my job. I might take care of it as a result of I do know my rights, however what concerning the hundreds of staff who don’t know their rights? Folks have been deported only for attempting to vary corporations.
Fifa talks so much about “truthful play”. Is it actually truthful play when there’s nothing for the employees? Sure, plenty of staff acquired employment but it surely was underneath exploitative circumstances. I believe a rustic’s human rights document needs to be a part of the analysis course of when awarding a World Cup. For Fifa, it was an afterthought.
-
Geoffrey, a Kenyan, labored in Qatar for 3 and a half years. Whereas there, he additionally labored for the human rights group Equidem as a researcher and advocate for staff’ rights. He was detained thrice and has now returned residence, the place he continues his advocacy work
Max Tuñón: ‘Now staff can negotiate for higher circumstances’
Earlier this 12 months, we commissioned a survey amongst 1,000 low-wage staff, and located that 86% of respondents felt that the labour reforms had positively affected their lives.
Modifications to the kafala system have led to labour mobility. Now staff can negotiate for higher circumstances, and employers are incentivised to offer them with a view to appeal to and retain expertise.
Laws has additionally been launched on the minimal wage, on defending out of doors staff in the course of the summer time months, and on the election of migrant employee representatives inside corporations.
Over the previous 5 years, the federal government has engaged intently with the ILO [International Labour Organization], worldwide commerce unions, NGOs and others. Notably, workers from the worldwide unions are based mostly with us right here in Doha, elevating consciousness amongst staff, and serving to them to resolve the issues they face.
There’s common acknowledgment that the work shouldn’t be full. Amongst our high priorities, there’s the necessity to deal with the retaliation by some employers in opposition to staff who want to change jobs; to streamline entry to justice and the restoration of due wages; and to make sure that the legislation defending home staff is absolutely applied.
We’re all impatient to see the reforms absolutely utilized and enforced, however we additionally recognise that we’re coping with new legal guidelines and new establishments, and altering practices which have been deeply entrenched for many years.
The World Cup was by no means the end line, however somewhat a key milestone in Qatar’s longer-term technique, which incorporates competing for expert staff in an more and more international market.
Building supervisor: ‘All they need is to tick packing containers’
The businesses I work for are simply getting away with all the things. There are lots of folks now strolling round Qatar who’ve misplaced their jobs, haven’t obtained their end-of-service advantages or months of wage. I’ve seen plenty of good folks undergo and it’s completely linked to the World Cup.
Qatar needed to construct all the things as cheaply as potential. All the massive contractors have been combating each other to win the work. They have been successful jobs at any price. As Qatar began slowing down its development [before the World Cup], all these contractors then began to face issues … and the place they save their cash is by not paying suppliers or our salaries and finish of companies.
All the federal government and supreme committee [the local body organising the World Cup] wish to do is tick packing containers, present a superb report and simply hope and pray that nobody finds out.
I’ve labored on plenty of World Cup tasks and we had good staff’ lodging and dangerous staff’ lodging. We did all our inspections on the good lodging. That is the way it works.
There’s no accountability. The federal government doesn’t implement its personal legal guidelines successfully. They did enable staff to vary jobs … however the dangerous corporations have been shedding all their staff, so the homeowners went to the federal government and stated, “Cease this.”
It’s 50% the contractors’ fault and 50% the federal government’s fault. The nation is simply too small for them to not know what’s occurring.
As soon as the World Cup’s completed, that’s it. The eyes of the world will not be on Qatar. They’ll simply return to how they have been.
Vani Saraswathi: ‘The true check will occur after the World Cup’
Qatar has made vital strides by way of labour reforms previously 5 years. In a area hostile to civil society interventions or criticism, Qatar has engaged with its critics. Little doubt the World Cup was efficient leverage to compel it to take action.
Once we communicate of reforms, now we have two fundamental elements – in precept, what’s been applied and, in observe, what’s been enforced. A lot of our concern is with the latter.
The elimination of the no-objection certificates [which workers required from their employer in order to change jobs] was by far crucial of the modifications. It gave migrant staff a possibility to faucet into the native job marketplace for higher alternatives. For the primary few months, the job change course of was nearly seamless, till employers began pushing again. Different components of the kafala system, significantly the facility of employers to report staff as “absconding”, have been misused to maintain staff in test, negating to a big diploma the effectiveness of the reforms.
Advocates for Qatar preserve arguing – weakly, for my part – that cultural change will take longer and what should be appreciated are the modifications in legislation. This isn’t about tradition however selective reforms that also give energy to the employer.
The true check, and the actual alternative for significant change, will occur after the World Cup. The relentless – and, at occasions, unfair – scrutiny Qatar has confronted within the final 12 years means reforms and reactions have been to primarily beat back criticism, with out specializing in buy-in and behavioural change domestically. In consequence, the highly effective enterprise homeowners cock a snook on the reforms and proceed unchecked with their exploitative practices.
I’d prefer to imagine Qatar is not going to regress on its authorized commitments post-2022, but when they’re to be enforced, it can require dialogue on the grassroots degree to indicate that guaranteeing the human rights of migrant staff and enterprise profitability shouldn’t be a zero-sum sport.
-
Vani Saraswathi is the editor-at-large of the web site for Migrant Rights, an organisation that advocates for migrant rights throughout the Gulf
Pete Pattisson: ‘The system is successfully nonetheless in place’
Qatar’s two flagship labour reforms are the introduction of a minimal wage and the abolition of the kafala system. The primary is a scandal, the second largely a failure.
The minimum wage is the equal of about £1 an hour. That is poverty pay, in one of many richest international locations on the earth per capita. Employers should additionally present meals and board, or an extra allowance to pay for them. The meals allowance is about £2 a day.
The abolition of kafala labored for just a few months, however at this time the system is successfully nonetheless in place. On my current visits to Qatar, nearly each employee I spoke to stated they have been unable to change jobs, leaving them on the mercy of abusive employers.
Each reforms solely got here into pressure 10 years after Qatar gained the best to host the World Cup, and lengthy after a lot of the stadiums and infrastructure have been accomplished.
That’s not to say nothing has modified, however each declare of reform the Qatari authorities make needs to be closely caveated.
New staff’ lodging has been constructed, however many hundreds nonetheless reside in squalid, overcrowded dorms.
The World Cup organising committee has launched a scheme to partially reimburse the large illegal fees staff are pressured to pay to safe their jobs, but it surely solely advantages a fraction of Qatar’s low-wage workforce.
Laws have been put in place to restrict labourers’ publicity to the searing summer time warmth, however the authorities have completed little to analyze the sudden and unexplained deaths of hundreds of staff. Numerous households of deceased staff have been left without compensation.
The Qatari authorities and Fifa declare the World Cup will depart a long-lasting legacy of higher staff’ rights within the nation and the area. That appears unlikely. A number of the reforms have stalled even earlier than a ball has been kicked.
Source link
