With the 49ers and Cowboys each among the many prime groups within the NFC this season, a debate of Brock Purdy vs Dak Prescott appears inevitable. Clearly, they aren’t the one two good quarterbacks within the NFL, nor are they able to be thought of among the many greatest quarterbacks of all time. However each have achieved nice success after being missed popping out of school, so the Prescott vs Purdy comparability is a good one.
Debating Brock Purdy vs Dak Prescott
Clearly, Prescott is a extra established participant whereas Purdy has taken the league by storm over the past season and a half. They’re each professional MVP candidates in 2023 and neither could be thought of among the many worst Super Bowl-winning quarterbacks in the event that they had been to steer their staff to a championship this season.
With MVP speak for each beginning to warmth up, let’s take a better have a look at Purdy and Prescott and the way they examine to 1 one other.
The Resume
Evidently, Prescott has an extended and extra spectacular resume than Purdy, He gained Offensive Rookie of the Yr honors in 2016 regardless of being a fourth-round decide, main Dallas to a 13-3 file in his first season. Prescott made the Professional Bowl that season whereas setting rookie data for finest completion proportion and passer score by a rookie. He returned to the Professional Bowl in 2018 and is prone to surpass 200 profession landing passes by the tip of the 2023 season.
Purdy hasn’t had as a lot time to place collectively a resume just like the one Prescott has. Most of Purdy’s accomplishments are seen by way of the lens of being the final participant chosen within the 2022 Draft. Nevertheless, Purdy did issues early in his profession that no different quarterback has completed. He was the primary quarterback to win his first six begins whereas throwing not less than two landing passes in every sport. Purdy additionally joined Aaron Rodgers as the one quarterbacks with a passer score of not less than 115 of their first two profession begins.
Creating Large Performs
There is no such thing as a query that Prescott has created greater than his justifiable share of massive performs all through his profession. It’s why he’s thrown not less than 22 landing passes yearly besides the 2020 season when he solely performed 5 video games. He’s additionally averaged over eight yards per move over a full season thrice and undoubtedly has the arm expertise to push the ball down the sector.
But, Purdy is averaging over 9 yards per move over the primary 17 begins of his profession. He wasn’t chosen till the ultimate decide of the draft largely as a result of he lacks the prototypical measurement and arm power of an elite quarterback. However whereas Purdy is commonly thought of extra of a sport supervisor as a result of he was missed popping out of school and has a terrific supporting solid, the numbers say he’s a quarterback who creates large performs.
Minimizing Errors
Limiting turnovers is notoriously an space the place Prescott has struggled, particularly in large video games. He has twice led the NFL in fumbles and in addition led the league in interceptions in 2022. In 4 of his first seven seasons within the league, Prescott threw not less than 10 interceptions. He additionally has 5 profession interceptions in six playoff video games, including to the notion that Prescott is careless with the soccer.
Quite the opposite, Purdy has been extra cautious with the soccer throughout the early a part of his profession. He owns a decrease interception proportion than Prescott and didn’t throw any in his first three playoff begins final season. In equity, Prescott and Purdy have thrown the identical variety of interceptions by way of the primary 12 video games of the 2023 season. Nevertheless, Purdy threw 5 of his six interceptions this 12 months throughout a three-game stoop. Since he’s come out of it, Purdy has been dependable in relation to ball safety, which stays a problem for Prescott.
Successful Video games
Finally, the whole lot boils all the way down to profitable video games, and Purdy has completed nothing however win since turning into San Francisco’s starter. Together with the playoffs, he owns a 16-4 file by way of the primary 20 begins of his profession. That features the loss in final 12 months’s NFC Championship Recreation after he obtained harm.
In equity, Prescott has gained almost 63% of his begins since coming to the NFL, which is nothing to scoff at. As talked about, he went 13-3 as a rookie, following a 12 months during which the Cowboys went 4-12. Nevertheless, there have been years that Prescott and the Cowboys underperformed primarily based on the requirements he set for himself early in his profession. Prescott’s 2-4 file within the playoffs additionally hangs over his head, particularly when in comparison with Purdy, who gained his first two playoff begins, together with a head-to-head sport over Prescott and the Cowboys.
The Verdict
Within the present second, the controversy between Prescott and Purdy has to lean towards Purdy. Prescott clearly has the sting in relation to expertise and longevity. However whereas that helps him in some methods, it makes his struggles within the playoffs and with ball safety tougher to disregard. It’s additionally onerous to disregard the truth that Prescott is beginning to run out of alternatives to win a Tremendous Bowl and cement his legacy.
Alternatively, it’s onerous to leap to conclusions about Purdy as a result of his physique of labor isn’t sufficiently big simply but. He’s clearly had the benefit of taking part in alongside some electrical playmakers with the 49ers and being supported by one of many NFL’s finest defenses. Nevertheless, the whole lot about Purdy’s numbers, the attention check, and the best way he performs the sport say that his success isn’t a fluke. He’s completed sufficient in his first 20 begins to be thought of a greater quarterback than Prescott and a critical MVP candidate in 2023.
Source link
